Introduction of the Speakers
The presentation on “Co-creating an Ecosystem for Restorative Practices in India” was delivered by:
- Arlene Manoharan & Swagata Raha: Co-Directors of the Restorative Practices team at Enfold Proactive Health Trust. Their work focuses on adapting, embedding, and scaling restorative principles within systems that deal with children, particularly those affected by child sexual abuse and the juvenile justice system.
- Their professional journey includes significant work in legal and policy reform concerning child rights, leading them to champion Restorative Practices (RP) as a powerful alternative to punitive systems.
Summary of Additional Resources and Context
The resources provided offer specific context and details about the programs mentioned in the presentation, highlighting Enfold’s commitment to documentation, research, and collaborative work.
Enfold: The Organization
- Enfold Proactive Health Trust is a leading Indian non-profit working since 2001 on the prevention of and response to child sexual abuse, championing a child-centered and child rights-based approach.
Key Publications Mentioned in the Talk
These publications provide empirical evidence and detailed methodologies supporting the work discussed by Arlene Manoharan and Swagata Raha:
- Handbook for Facilitation of Restorative Practices in Child Care Institutions (2021):
- This resource, supported by UNICEF, directly relates to the state-level capacity building program discussed in the presentation (the replication of the Nanus Samartha model).
- It serves as a practical guide for staff in Child Care Institutions (CCIs), enabling them to shift institutional culture from punitive to restorative, thereby transforming CCIs into child-friendly spaces.
- Swagata Raha, “Pathways and Possibilities for Restorative Justice in India’s Juvenile Justice System” (2020):
- This academic chapter directly stems from the speakers’ early policy advocacy journey (2013-2015), where they researched alternatives to the retributive backlash following the 2012 Delhi gang rape.
- It provides a legal and policy analysis of incorporating restorative principles into India’s Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, offering judicial and legislative pathways for implementation.
- Life Skills Through Restorative Circles… Innisfree House School (2020):
- This document summarizes the results of the pioneering school pilot program mentioned in the talk, believed to be the first of its kind in India.
- It details how restorative circles were used to develop life skills among students and staff, demonstrating the practical application of RP in educational settings to foster community and address conflict.
- Demystifying Sexuality Reference Book (2021):
- This publication reflects Enfold’s overarching mission, integrating their core work on child sexual abuse prevention with their restorative philosophy.
- It adopts a rights-based, restorative, and gender-transformative lens to discuss sexuality, showcasing how RP values inform their comprehensive approach to child protection and dignity.
Review and Summary of the Presentation to RJ World
The presentation detailed the journey of Enfold’s Restorative Practices team from advocacy to implementation, focusing on co-creating an ecosystem rooted in ecosystem awareness (Theory U) as an alternative to punitive, retributive systems.
Summary of Presentation Highlights
| Phase | Description | Key Programs/Concepts |
| Foundation & Catalyst | Enfold was moved by the post-2012 push for punitive justice to actively seek restorative alternatives. This started their legal research and advocacy journey for Restorative Justice (RJ). | Policy Advocacy, Theory U, Ego-system vs. Ecosystem Awareness. |
| Practice Implementation | Following training with international experts, the team established practical applications in institutions and communities. The pandemic response led to innovative adaptations. | RP Circles in CCIs, School Pilot, Nanus Samartha (online circles with discharged youth). |
| Systemic Scaling | The success of Nanus Samartha led to a partnership with the Government of Karnataka to train all CCI staff, promoting systemic change across the state. They also began specialized reintegration circles. | State-level Capacity Building, Reintegration Circles. |
| Ecosystem Building | The current focus is on building solidarity networks among partner NGOs and working with Unicef to achieve convergence across programs aimed at transforming CCIs. They integrate global RJ wisdom with indigenous practices (e.g., Panchayati Raj). | Donor Networks, Unicef Convergence, Community Praxis Circles, Integrating Indigenous Wisdom. |
Review for the RJ World Audience
The presentation offers valuable insights for the global RJ community, particularly because of its systemic breadth and cultural depth:
- Policy to Praxis: The presenters established their RP work on the foundation of intensive legal and comparative research, providing strong legitimacy for their programs.
- Adaptability: The rapid and successful transition to online circles during the pandemic with marginalized youth demonstrated the resilience and adaptability of RP methods.
- Authenticity and Sustainability: The emphasis on the team’s need for daily “pruning” and practice circles highlights a critical aspect of sustainability and self-care necessary for long-term work in challenging fields.
- Holistic Scope: By applying RP principles across five academic curricula, partnering with the government, and engaging in policy writing, Enfold is not just running programs; they are actively working to institutionalize restorative values at every level of the child protection system.